Beyond a reasonable doubt. I believe the reasonable is where emotions and logic meet because a mother killed her kids. Emotionally and logically that is not (also society wants it not to be) reasonable or logical.
But as a society we just can’t automatically allow a mother to kill her children without criminal responsibility because of res ipsa loquitur. The act of a mother killing her kids can’t be the thing that proves she is insane. As society we can’t allow that.
I look at reasonable doubt as a bouncer at a club. It decides what evidence comes in to prove quilt. All others have to stay out because that evidence is unreasonable. I also believe juries are allowed to use their common sense and life experiences as well. Just like the bouncer in letting folks in.
I think it is unreasonable for her to have told her ex she had thoughts of harming her children but didn’t until a voice told her. She told her ex she had thoughts of harming them but didn’t tell him of the voice but sent him out of the house. She didn’t argue with or fight the voice but she was able to fight the urge to kill het children up unto the voice? Why didn’t she tell her ex of the voice?
I would not allow that evidence past the bouncer at the door. It us unreasonable
What is left.
She meet with multiple mental health experts. She was medicated. Including admitting herself to McLean . She was not diagnosed with psychosis. She was depressed, suicidal but no diagnosis of psychosis from multiple health professionals and a mental institution.
This is reasonable verifiable evidence. This evidence gets past the bouncer.
Also there is a question of why didn’t Patrick tell the health professionals of her having thoughts or afraid of harming the kids?
I think it is reasonable to believe that if they had the kids would have most likely been removed from her in someway.
Also I think short of mental health professionals acquiring the abilities to read a patient’s mind, they didn’t fail her. I think this notion needs to stop.
The adults around those kids failed them not the mental health professionals failed a sane woman who killed her kids.
Because people under report symptoms, especially with regard to voices and severity. This is so common they teach us about this in clinics and schooling. You cant find someone liable because you're afraid this will give other women "permission" to kill their kids. 🤦🏼♀️
Women are making this case about mental health resources and post partum depression and psychosis legitimacy. You can convict Clancy snd not punish the mentally ill and women too.
When does post partum
Depression and psychosis end after birth? If 8 months fine then why not 36?
my understanding is while she was prescribed 13 medications she was never on more than 3-4 medications at a time — which is not to discredit the very real possibility or even likelihood she was suffering from psychosis but it does muddy the waters even more. None of us want to believe illness could make an otherwise stable and loving person kill their children because then we’d have to contend with the reality it could happen to us too. It’s a truly heartbreaking and terrifying case.
100% Zeynep, that's part of what makes this case so terrifying: having to accept that severe mental illness can potentially transform the behavior of someone who, until then, seemed loving and stable. That is a very uncomfortable reality to contemplate.
No I think she knew enough to get the husband out. If you cannot cope you should give the kids to someone who can. Three young lives stolen and I think it is dangerous as a precedent to let her off for murder.
How are the fact that she demonstrated the ability to plan her murders and then executed those murders not a clear part of the discussion? Also why do women not understand that essentially her being found innocent is the equivalent of saying you as a sex are unable to be held accountable for your decision making due to your hormones? Like as an alarmingly right wing young man, I am not going to complain but still…
The idea of not guilty by reason of insanity should not be a criminal defense. It’s a travesty it is. It allows criminals to avoid punishment and is a recent legal defense that should be abolished.
Patrick should have left his crazy wife and kept the kids. Then they’d be alive. I doubt Lindsey’s supporters would have liked that outcome.
The question is just whether or not she was experiencing psychosis. For reference, about 3 in 100 people experience psychosis at some point in the life. The rate of postpartum psychosis is quite a bit lower, so it really isn't a gender issue at all, and (as always) the case should be decided purely on the facts.
What all layman people don't understand is that someone can be really psychotic and look fine and behave "normal". Ive worked with clients who have active hallucinations daily, even with medications. I had a client check-in, report being fine. Then the following day kill their animals and themselves. The medical providers are at fault as there was no continuity of care nor did they engage more aggressively when she reported thoughts of harming her children. That should have been a giant red flag. She is guilty of killing her children. The defense has not even remotely shown that she was sane though.
“And there is something else that I want you to consider: psychosis does not necessarily look like psychosis.”
NGRI pleas should be barred if this is going to be the evidentiary standard applied. She just had that really subtle psychosis where you’re normal in every way except for the one time you commit a devastating brutal crime, and then you snap out of it just in time to design the legal defense?
You’re making that up. That claim was never made. And she’s being medicated for multiple disorders. Obviously she is not postpartum anymore, but she can still struggle with postpartum disorders for years after developing them. You honestly have zero idea what’s happening beyond what AI tells you and that’s obvious by the crap you just made up
Beyond a reasonable doubt. I believe the reasonable is where emotions and logic meet because a mother killed her kids. Emotionally and logically that is not (also society wants it not to be) reasonable or logical.
But as a society we just can’t automatically allow a mother to kill her children without criminal responsibility because of res ipsa loquitur. The act of a mother killing her kids can’t be the thing that proves she is insane. As society we can’t allow that.
I look at reasonable doubt as a bouncer at a club. It decides what evidence comes in to prove quilt. All others have to stay out because that evidence is unreasonable. I also believe juries are allowed to use their common sense and life experiences as well. Just like the bouncer in letting folks in.
I think it is unreasonable for her to have told her ex she had thoughts of harming her children but didn’t until a voice told her. She told her ex she had thoughts of harming them but didn’t tell him of the voice but sent him out of the house. She didn’t argue with or fight the voice but she was able to fight the urge to kill het children up unto the voice? Why didn’t she tell her ex of the voice?
I would not allow that evidence past the bouncer at the door. It us unreasonable
What is left.
She meet with multiple mental health experts. She was medicated. Including admitting herself to McLean . She was not diagnosed with psychosis. She was depressed, suicidal but no diagnosis of psychosis from multiple health professionals and a mental institution.
This is reasonable verifiable evidence. This evidence gets past the bouncer.
Also there is a question of why didn’t Patrick tell the health professionals of her having thoughts or afraid of harming the kids?
I think it is reasonable to believe that if they had the kids would have most likely been removed from her in someway.
Also I think short of mental health professionals acquiring the abilities to read a patient’s mind, they didn’t fail her. I think this notion needs to stop.
The adults around those kids failed them not the mental health professionals failed a sane woman who killed her kids.
Because people under report symptoms, especially with regard to voices and severity. This is so common they teach us about this in clinics and schooling. You cant find someone liable because you're afraid this will give other women "permission" to kill their kids. 🤦🏼♀️
Women are making this case about mental health resources and post partum depression and psychosis legitimacy. You can convict Clancy snd not punish the mentally ill and women too.
When does post partum
Depression and psychosis end after birth? If 8 months fine then why not 36?
Without a diagnosis, yes.
I am not sure if you are aware of the moral decay in the world we live in now.
But killing a child/children is not shameful nor shunned by a shocking number of people now.
If a person under reports then kills their kids, NOT societies problem.
So judgmental. I hope you never have a crisis. No one helped her. Including people like you.
At least they're not a child killer
my understanding is while she was prescribed 13 medications she was never on more than 3-4 medications at a time — which is not to discredit the very real possibility or even likelihood she was suffering from psychosis but it does muddy the waters even more. None of us want to believe illness could make an otherwise stable and loving person kill their children because then we’d have to contend with the reality it could happen to us too. It’s a truly heartbreaking and terrifying case.
100% Zeynep, that's part of what makes this case so terrifying: having to accept that severe mental illness can potentially transform the behavior of someone who, until then, seemed loving and stable. That is a very uncomfortable reality to contemplate.
No I think she knew enough to get the husband out. If you cannot cope you should give the kids to someone who can. Three young lives stolen and I think it is dangerous as a precedent to let her off for murder.
It's funny that not only are you completely wrong about this, but you also had to have AI help you be completely wrong about it.
Guilty! She knew exactly what she was doing.
Guilty, immediate execution.
How are the fact that she demonstrated the ability to plan her murders and then executed those murders not a clear part of the discussion? Also why do women not understand that essentially her being found innocent is the equivalent of saying you as a sex are unable to be held accountable for your decision making due to your hormones? Like as an alarmingly right wing young man, I am not going to complain but still…
She manually strangled 3 children 1 by one in front of each other. Anyone who has any questions is just like her.
The idea of not guilty by reason of insanity should not be a criminal defense. It’s a travesty it is. It allows criminals to avoid punishment and is a recent legal defense that should be abolished.
Patrick should have left his crazy wife and kept the kids. Then they’d be alive. I doubt Lindsey’s supporters would have liked that outcome.
The question is just whether or not she was experiencing psychosis. For reference, about 3 in 100 people experience psychosis at some point in the life. The rate of postpartum psychosis is quite a bit lower, so it really isn't a gender issue at all, and (as always) the case should be decided purely on the facts.
Get a life a soul and a heart. And mostly fuck off. Weird abusive men.
What all layman people don't understand is that someone can be really psychotic and look fine and behave "normal". Ive worked with clients who have active hallucinations daily, even with medications. I had a client check-in, report being fine. Then the following day kill their animals and themselves. The medical providers are at fault as there was no continuity of care nor did they engage more aggressively when she reported thoughts of harming her children. That should have been a giant red flag. She is guilty of killing her children. The defense has not even remotely shown that she was sane though.
“And there is something else that I want you to consider: psychosis does not necessarily look like psychosis.”
NGRI pleas should be barred if this is going to be the evidentiary standard applied. She just had that really subtle psychosis where you’re normal in every way except for the one time you commit a devastating brutal crime, and then you snap out of it just in time to design the legal defense?
She didn’t snap out of it. She’s currently heavily medicated as she’s still struggling and she’s under the care of loads of doctors right now.
Her testimony is that she snapped out of it and tried to kill herself out of horror and guilt but that she’s fine now
She’s medicated for depression
She’s no longer postpartum; if you accept her plea she has to be let go because she’s cured
You’re making that up. That claim was never made. And she’s being medicated for multiple disorders. Obviously she is not postpartum anymore, but she can still struggle with postpartum disorders for years after developing them. You honestly have zero idea what’s happening beyond what AI tells you and that’s obvious by the crap you just made up